CNBC – Clearly Jim Goldman Knows Nothing About Computers.
The following is an e-mail I sent to CNBC after watching the video above:
Dear CNBC,
I am a computer scientist, and was appalled when I heard the claims made by your “tech analyst” Jim Goldman.
When it comes to Windows vs. Mac, I take neither side because I use Linux. (Hey, how about you do a story on how Linux and other open source software is free, and can save people hundreds of dollars?)
The information that Jim Goldman provided was incredibly false. Here are a few things:
Claims:
1.) PC’s need a $50/yr Norton Anti-virus subscription. This is simply not true. Colleges have been promoting FREE alternatives such as AVG and Avast. You do not need to pay for an anti-virus software.
2.) Jim Goldman claims that Mac’s come with Photoshop. This is simply not true, and incredibly misleading.
3.) Multimedia Software – $80-$104???? Why? What software? Windows comes with Windows Media Player, Windows Media Center, and you can get iTunes for free. In terms of pictures, Windows Picture Album works fine, and there are also free alternatives to use.
4.) Video Editing – What about Windows Movie Maker? Does that not count? It comes FREE with Windows.
5.) Music Software – $100? I am sorry, but this is beyond ridiculous. Windows comes with Windows Media Player. Also, iTunes is FREE. Mac’s use iTunes. There are also many free, and popular alternatives such as VLC, RealPlayer, etc. If you are taking about recording music, yes you can get a version of ProTools, or other recording software for $100 for PC. However, this software is MUCH better than garage band which comes with a Mac.
6.) Geek Squad Visit – $129? You can get a local computer shop to fix a PC for much cheaper.
7.) Mac Battery life 4x better – This is just completely false. If you want battery life, get a netbook which runs for 9 hours on a single charge. Also, my Lenovo laptop gets 3.15 hours on my battery, while my friends MacBook gets 4-5 hours. That is not 4x better.
8.) Faster Chip – This is absolutely terrible. Mac’s use the SAME PROCESSOR AS WINDOWS MACHINES. The Intel processors that Mac’s use are also available on PC. Oh, and guess what, Mac’s do not use the latest Intel processors. When Intel releases a new CPU, it is immediately available for PC users, but it takes awhile for Mac to offer them in their products.
I cannot believe that Jim Goldman is your “senior tech analyst”. This is some of the absolute worst journalism I have ever seen. These claims NEED to be clarified and the truth needs to get out to the people who are shopping for PC’s. If you want to help people save money and get quality software, why don’t you do a story on Ubuntu and Open Source software?
How dare you try to convince people, especially in a struggling economy, that they need to spend more money based on completely false evidence.